עיכוב הודעת בדבר מות חולה

שתפו:

23 באוקטובר 2018

הרב המשיב: הרב ד"ר מרדכי הלפרין

שאלה:

Hi there

I wonder if you can help

On Friday I did a ward round and found one of my patients dead. This was very unexpected, there were no warning signs and he had been fine a few minutes before.

I needed to inform the corroner as a post-mortem needs to be done in these cases (I hope this is OK – he was a Goy).

The next thing is I needed to tell his family. the only number I had was of his 80 year old wife whom I had never met. I called her and asked her to come in and see me. She said she was comming in any case with her daughter in a few hours. She became suspicious and asked if her husband was dead. I felt it reasonale to lie in this situatuion and I told her no , but please come in I need to speak to you. I felt that I could not tell her the news over the phone, alone and I was unable to comfort her over the phone or assess the help she needed.

I called her in and told her.

Some of the staff here are upset with me and feel I should have been honest.

What do you feel?

תשובה:

To tell a person about the death of a close family member might be danger.

Therefore the way you handled the case was the right way, both ethically and Halachiclly.

להדפסה

שאלות נוספות

שז"ל

בס"ד שלום! קצת לא נעים לי לשאול אבל זה עדיף מאשר להמשיך לחטוא ואין לי ברירה אחרת. קראתי באחת השאלות שמשהו אמר שיש מקום שעל

קרא עוד »

תופעה אורתופדית

שלום רב! לגבי תופעה של רגל אחת ארוכה ורגל שניה קצת יותר קצרה כך שהם לא באותו גובה וזה כנראה יוצר בעיות. אני מכירה מישהו

קרא עוד »
Translate »

מה אתם מחפשים?