Aborting under the advice of one doctor

שתפו:

26 ביוני 2009

שאלה:

Shalom rav,

I was just asked the following question, which I would like to present to you. The lady who asked me is pregnant in the 9th week of gestation. Two weeks ago, i.e. in the 7th week of gestation, an ultrasound was performed. It demonstrated that the embryo has had a heartbeat and was therefore viable. Now, two weeks later, a repeated ultrasound revealed absent heartbeat. The gynaekologist declared that an intrauterine death of the embryo has occured and recommended the lady to let an abortion be performed.

Questions:

1. Is it pertinent to rely on the opinion of only one gynaekologist i.e., is there an obligation to consult another specialist?
2. Is the absent heartbeat a halachically sufficient proof of death of the embryo? Or is only the case if proven on several occasions at different points of time?
3. Should the death of the embryo be thereby proven, are there any halchically specific features of such an abortion?

I would be very much obliged for an answer before Shabbos, since the lady in question is under considerable emotional stress.

Thanks in advance / kol tuv

P R

תשובה:

If the lack of a pulse has been confirmed in the second scan, taking into account the existence of a pulse in the past – it is a conformation that the embryo expired around the 9th week

להדפסה

שאלות נוספות

כנס ציץ אליעזר

לרב ד"ר הלפרין נהניתי מאוד מהכנס שהתקיים אתמול. דברי הקישור שלך היו תורה וחכמה במקום אחד. אני מקווה שהכנס הוקלט ותומלל וניתן יהיה להשיג את

קרא עוד »

בנוגע לרפואה אלטרנטיבית

שלום כבוד הרב ד"ר מרדכי הלפרין!רציתי לשאול האם מעמד של אוקופונקטורה ורפואה סינית בכלל  נדון בשו"ת ופסקי דינים בנוגע לשאלת של "אביזרייהו דעבודה זרה" במקור

קרא עוד »
Translate »

מה אתם מחפשים?